Security enforcer setup

I have set a security provider enforcer on the page level, like this:

These are my settings for the security provider:

Knipsel.PNG1595×563 58.6 KB

It seems like I have set everything correctly, but when I enforce the page to only view if you’re an admin, it sends me to the unauthorized page (index.php in our case). When I set the permission level to ‘all’, an admin can view the page. Am I missing something?